Leadership Is About Seeing the Best in Others
Borrowed brilliance challenges the belief that leaders must personally generate every valuable idea. Strong leadership often begins by recognising the insight, experience, and creativity already present within a team.
There is a persistent myth surrounding leadership. The strongest leaders are supposedly the originators of every strategy, vision, solution, and innovation.
This expectation can create unnecessary pressure. Leaders may feel they must enter every meeting with the answer already formed.
Yet schools rarely improve because one person produces a perfect idea. They improve when people contribute, challenge, refine, test, and strengthen ideas together.
Borrowed brilliance is not a leadership weakness. It is the wisdom to recognise that the best thinking may come from anywhere.
Leadership Is Not an Ideas Competition
Leadership should never become a competition for intellectual ownership. The aim is not to prove who thought of something first.
The aim is to improve learning, strengthen culture, and help people succeed. That requires leaders to place organisational purpose above personal recognition.
A teacher may discover a more effective feedback routine. A coordinator may develop a better approach to collaborative planning.
A support team member may identify an operational problem before senior leaders notice it. Students may also recognise barriers that adults have gradually accepted.
Effective leaders notice these contributions. They then create opportunities for good ideas to travel across the organisation.
This approach connects closely with The Leadership Echo. What leaders choose to amplify often becomes part of the school’s culture.
Three Roles of the Collaborative Leader
Borrowed brilliance requires leaders to perform three important roles.
Curators of great practice
Curators look carefully for effective practice already happening within the organisation. They identify what works and consider where else it may have value.
This requires leaders to remain close to classrooms, teams, and daily operations. Valuable ideas are often found through observation rather than formal presentations.
Amplifiers of staff voice
Amplifiers ensure that worthwhile contributions are heard beyond their original setting. They create platforms where staff can share practice, experience, and professional insight.
Amplifying does not mean speaking on someone else’s behalf without recognition. It means helping their thinking reach people who may benefit from it.
Translators who connect ideas to action
Not every strong idea arrives in a complete or polished form. Leaders must often connect fragments of insight across different conversations.
They help teams understand why an idea matters. They also connect it with strategic priorities, available resources, and practical next steps.
Borrowed brilliance therefore involves judgement. Leaders must distinguish between an interesting suggestion and an idea worth developing.
Credit Builds Trust
Leaders weaken trust when they present another person’s idea as their own. Even when this happens unintentionally, people notice.
Public recognition communicates that contribution matters. It also encourages others to share ideas without fearing that their work will disappear into leadership language.
Simple statements can make a significant difference:
- “This idea came from our Year 4 teaching team.”
- “Maria raised this possibility during our planning meeting.”
- “Our students helped us recognise this problem.”
- “We have adapted a practice developed at another campus.”
Attribution does not reduce leadership authority. It demonstrates confidence, fairness, and professional integrity.
When people know their thinking will be respected, they contribute more openly. Shared ownership then becomes part of everyday practice.
Create Conditions for Shared Thinking
Leaders cannot borrow brilliance from teams that are rarely invited to think. Staff voice requires structures, time, and psychological safety.
Meetings should contain space for contribution rather than only information delivery. Professional learning should allow staff to demonstrate practice, not simply receive instructions.
Leaders can also ask better questions:
- What are we already doing well?
- Who has solved part of this problem?
- What have students or families noticed?
- Which idea could we test before making a larger decision?
- Whose perspective have we not yet heard?
This requires the measured leadership described in Leadership Without Rush. Leaders must slow down sufficiently to hear what others are saying.
From Borrowing to Building
Borrowed brilliance should never become simple imitation. Ideas must be examined, adapted, and tested within their new context.
A practice that succeeds in one classroom may need adjustment elsewhere. A strategy from another school may not fit the needs of your community.
Leaders should protect the original insight while allowing others to improve it. The strongest ideas often develop through several rounds of professional contribution.
This creates a culture where people build upon one another’s thinking. Innovation becomes a shared process rather than an individual performance.
Leadership is not diminished when an idea comes from someone else. Leadership is demonstrated through recognising its value and helping it produce meaningful change.
This Week’s Prompt
Whose ideas will you borrow, spotlight, or build upon this week?
Look beyond the loudest voices and formal leadership positions. Someone within your organisation may already hold part of the answer you need.
Looking for more? You might like to read Why staff resistance happens after people ask for change or Building Effective Leadership Teams in Schools
Discover more from Dr Jake Madden
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
