Measuring School Leadership Performance: Key Self-Reflection Strategies

Measuring school leadership performance is essential for growth and effectiveness. Every school leader has an intuitive sense of how they are performing, but true improvement requires more than just gut feelings. Leaders must actively evaluate their impact and seek meaningful feedback.

Many school leaders view performance reviews as an administrative task rather than an opportunity for self-reflection. However, evaluating leadership performance doesn’t have to be a chore. It can be a powerful process that drives improvement, informs decision-making, and strengthens a school’s vision.

Here are four practical ways to measure school leadership performance and enhance professional growth.

1. Questionnaires & Self-Assessments

One of the most common tools for measuring school leadership performance is the 360-degree questionnaire. These surveys collect anonymous feedback from staff, providing charts and tables that highlight strengths and weaknesses. While these can be helpful, they often lack depth in identifying actionable steps for improvement.

A more effective approach is engaging in face-to-face conversations with staff. By actively listening and seeking direct feedback, leaders gain insightful perspectives on their impact. Honest discussions with teachers and colleagues can provide valuable reflections that a survey might miss.

2. Intuitive Reflection

Great leaders have strong intuition. They can sense when things are running smoothly and when something feels off. While intuition alone is not a structured measurement, it often signals areas that need attention.

By regularly reflecting on decision-making, staff morale, and school culture, leaders can make timely adjustments. The key is balancing instinct with data, ensuring that gut feelings align with measurable outcomes.

3. Examining Your School Community

A leader’s performance is reflected in the success of the school community. When leadership is effective:

• Teachers are engaged and aligned with the school’s vision.
• Student outcomes improve, both academically and socially.
• Middle leaders and teacher leaders thrive in their roles.
• A culture of collaboration and growth is evident.

If these elements are in place, it indicates strong leadership. However, if disengagement, confusion, or stagnation emerge, it may be time to re-evaluate leadership strategies.

4. Looking Beyond Your School

Strong school leadership extends beyond the school gates. Comparing your school’s performance, programs, and initiatives with other institutions offers valuable insights into effectiveness.

Key questions to ask include:

• How does our innovation compare to similar schools?
• Are our academic results improving in line with expectations?
• Are we forward-planning for future challenges?
• Are our leadership strategies fostering long-term success?

By keeping an eye on external benchmarks, leaders can adapt, innovate, and drive school improvement.

The First Step: A Desire to Improve

Ultimately, the foundation of measuring school leadership performance is a leader’s internal commitment to growth. No strategy, survey, or comparison will be effective unless there is a genuine desire to improve. Without this drive, leaders risk stagnation—and an absent leader can weaken an entire school community.

True leadership is about reflection, adaptation, and continuous improvement. By embracing self-evaluation and seeking meaningful feedback, school leaders can enhance their impact and create lasting change.

Please leave this field empty

Smart strategies for school leaders – in under 5 minutes a week.

Get weekly leadership insights —designed for educators, school leaders, and aspiring leaders.
Each issue offers a single theme, practical strategies, real-world reflections, and tools to help you lead with confidence, purpose, and impact.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Dr Jake Madden

I’m Jake Madden (Dip Teach; B.Ed; Grad Dip: Leadership; M. Ed: Leadership; EdD; FACEL; MACE), and I’ve had the privilege of working in education for over thirty years as a teacher and principal. Throughout my career, I’ve focused on supporting teachers to build their capacity, developing learning approaches that respond to the needs of today’s world, creating flexible learning spaces for 21st-century learners, and designing curriculum that encourages global mindedness. I’m particularly passionate about the concept of teacher-as-researcher, and I’ve been fortunate to contribute to this area by sharing my experiences through books and journal articles. My work reflects what I’ve learned from leading and navigating educational change, and I’m always eager to continue learning from others in the field.

See Full Bio

Author: Dr Jake Madden

I’m Jake Madden (Dip Teach; B.Ed; Grad Dip: Leadership; M. Ed: Leadership; EdD; FACEL; MACE), and I’ve had the privilege of working in education for over thirty years as a teacher and principal. Throughout my career, I’ve focused on supporting teachers to build their capacity, developing learning approaches that respond to the needs of today’s world, creating flexible learning spaces for 21st-century learners, and designing curriculum that encourages global mindedness. I’m particularly passionate about the concept of teacher-as-researcher, and I’ve been fortunate to contribute to this area by sharing my experiences through books and journal articles. My work reflects what I’ve learned from leading and navigating educational change, and I’m always eager to continue learning from others in the field. View all posts by Dr Jake Madden