Teacher professional learning (PL) is a topic that has been widely debated by school leaders, teacher learners, teacher unions, teacher leaders, universities, education institutions, and governments. This article examines the future difficulties for teacher PL from the perspective of teachers as researchers. Here are seven significant challenges that educators face in professional learning, along with insights on how school leaders can help overcome these issues.
1. Pressure on Schools to Perform More with Less
Schools are under increasing pressure to raise student achievement across a range of academic criteria, including reading and maths proficiency, as well as social and democratic values such as bullying prevention, student involvement in decision-making, and addressing health concerns like obesity. With schools and school leaders pushing for teacher-led systemic reform, teacher professional learning becomes even more essential.
However, the current environment demands that schools perform more with fewer resources, making effective PL programs even harder to implement. It’s critical for school leaders to establish clear pathways for teacher professional learning that align with the broader goals of the school and the professional growth of teachers.
2. Teacher Fatigue and Resistance to Traditional PL Approaches
Teacher fatigue or resistance is another challenge facing the future of teacher PL. In-service training, particularly the type that forces large groups of teachers into conferences without interaction or networking opportunities, is losing its effectiveness. As a result, the question arises: what is the alternative?
One solution is adopting a more job-embedded approach to PL, where the concept of the teacher as a researcher becomes more central. By involving teachers in the process of inquiry and reflective practice, professional development becomes more relevant and aligned with their day-to-day experiences.
3. The Focus of Teacher Education Institutions
Governments are placing increasing expectations on teacher education institutions, pushing them towards more accreditation-focused programs rather than preparing graduates who are ready to teach competently and effectively in schools. This challenge reflects a growing disconnect in teacher preparation that needs to be addressed.
As schools focus more on student outcomes, universities and educational agencies need to ensure that future teachers are prepared as professional educators who understand the importance of prioritising student learning.
4. The Constant Waves of Change in Schools
Australian schools, in particular, face regular changes in educational policy, curriculum, and testing requirements. These “waves of change” create uncertainty for teachers, as they struggle to understand their role in the evolving landscape. School leaders must step in and provide clarity on how these changes relate to student learning and how teachers can adapt to them.
What role can school leadership play in helping teachers navigate these changes? By providing consistent guidance and support, leaders can ensure teachers remain focused on improving student outcomes rather than becoming overwhelmed by the constant shifting demands.
5. The Need for Collaborative Teacher PL
Historically, teacher professional learning has been viewed as a teacher-focused endeavour, often isolated from other stakeholders such as teacher educators, school leaders, parents, and students. When teachers work alone, a lack of collaboration and idea-sharing can occur, hindering the effectiveness of PL programs.
To overcome this, teacher education institutions and school leaders must provide more opportunities for collaborative teacher professional learning. By creating spaces for teachers to engage with one another, share experiences, and work together on improvement initiatives, professional development can become more impactful.
6. Shifting from Knowledge Transfer to Reflective Practice
A significant shift is needed in how teacher preparation programs approach teacher professional learning. Historically, programs have focused on transferring knowledge through lectures and seminars, but this has led to a disconnect between theory and practice. To better support teachers as researchers, it’s crucial to enable ongoing personal reflection as part of their professional identity formation.
Teachers should be encouraged to engage in action research and inquiry into their own practice, asking questions and using data to drive improvements. Universities can play a key role in ensuring that school-based teacher research is supported and valued, creating stronger connections between theory and practice.
7. Developing Reflective Teacher Leaders
Lastly, teacher leaders must be reflective practitioners who continuously assess and adapt their teaching practices. However, this requires more than just an understanding of how to reflect—teacher leadership teams need support in developing and sustaining meaningful teacher professional learning initiatives.
By fostering a culture of continuous reflection and professional growth, school leaders can help teachers at all stages of their careers become effective leaders in their own right.
Overcoming Teacher PL Challenges: Potential Solutions
Here are a few suggestions to address these challenges, based on extensive research into teacher leadership and professional learning:
- Tailored PL Programs: Teacher education institutions can play a pivotal role by offering teacher programs that address the individual learning needs of teacher leaders, rather than simply focusing on generic teacher training. Personalised PL programs can better align with teachers’ goals for professional improvement.
- Collaborative Learning Opportunities: Teachers should be encouraged to observe and learn from one another by forming professional learning groups within schools. By engaging in shared inquiry and reflection, teachers can develop their skills and improve practice collectively.
- Reflecting on Teacher Development: Teacher development must be viewed as a holistic process, encompassing both professional education and ongoing learning in the classroom. Leaders should encourage reflection on the ways teachers learn and the types of support that best align with their teaching contexts.
- Principals as Supporters of Teacher Research: School leaders need opportunities to engage in constructive professional conversations about teacher research. By understanding how teachers conduct research and engage in reflective practice, principals can better support PL efforts within their schools.
Conclusion: The Need for Stronger Partnerships
The future of teacher professional learning requires stronger partnerships between schools and universities. Schools have the unique insight into what students need, while universities are critical in advancing research and leadership practices. By working more closely together, these institutions can better equip teacher leaders to support effective PL programs that cater to the diverse needs of educators at every stage of their career.
In summary, schools, universities, and teacher education institutions face numerous challenges in ensuring that teacher professional learning meets the evolving demands of the education system. With a focus on reflective practice, collaboration, and research-based approaches, school leaders can create pathways for overcoming these challenges and ensuring that teachers are well-equipped to support student success.
Discover more from Dr Jake Madden
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
