The Blind Spots Leaders Cannot See

Leadership blind spots are difficult to address because the leader often cannot see them. A behaviour that seems effective from one position may create a different experience for colleagues.

A decisive school leader may believe quick decisions keep work moving. Teachers may experience those decisions as closed discussions, where raising concerns feels unwelcome. The leader sees progress; the team learns to stay quiet.

This gap rarely begins with bad intentions. It often grows from habits that have helped a leader succeed, reinforced by the people and systems around them.

Strengths can become blind spots

Leadership strengths matter. Clear direction, confidence and persistence can help a school respond to difficult challenges. However, any strength can become less useful when applied in every situation.

Research by Robert Kaplan and Robert Kaiser describes how leaders can become lopsided, relying heavily on preferred qualities while neglecting complementary ones. A leader who drives action may underuse listening. Someone who builds consensus may delay decisions that need clarity. The issue is not the strength itself, but when its use no longer fits the situation.

Leaders may also misread why they succeeded. They remember the decisions that produced results and repeat the behaviours associated with them. If colleagues do not explain the costs, those habits can become stronger over time.

Silence can look like agreement

As leaders become more senior, colleagues may find it harder to offer candid feedback. They may worry about relationships, career prospects or being seen as obstructive. A leader can then mistake silence for confirmation that their approach is working.

Power can add to this distance. In a set of experiments, Galinsky and colleagues found that participants primed to feel powerful were less likely to consider another person’s perspective and were less accurate at reading emotional expressions. These findings do not describe every leader or every setting. They do suggest that position can make it easier to rely on one’s own view.

Team composition can reinforce the same pattern. Leaders often select people who have succeeded through similar approaches. A team of fast decision-makers may learn that questions slow progress. The leader then reads the quiet as alignment and moves faster still. Leadership blind spots grow when the team’s shared habits prevent useful differences from surfacing.

Ask people who can answer honestly

Self-reflection has value, but it cannot reveal everything. A leader can examine intentions and decisions while still missing their effect on others. Leadership blind spots concern that gap between what we mean to do and what people experience.

The people closest to a leader may be least able to name it. Look beyond the immediate team to trusted peers, an executive coach or an HR colleague who understands the organisation but is less dependent on the leader’s approval.

Ask a focused question: “What do I do too much of?” Then listen without explaining, correcting or asking the person to soften the message. If the answer feels uncomfortable, ask for a recent example and what effect it had.

A single conversation may not reveal the full picture. Ask several people separately, look for themes and consider which situations bring the behaviour out. Thank people for their candour, then report back on what you will examine or change.

Build a team that sees differently

A team does not need to disagree about everything. It does need enough difference in experience and judgement for assumptions to be tested. When recruiting or promoting, consider whether the team includes people who approach problems differently and can explain why.

Notice when you use one strength everywhere. If every challenge prompts you to take control, ask whether the team needs direction, discussion or time to investigate. If you regularly seek agreement, consider whether the group needs a clear decision and a named owner.

Leadership blind spots cannot be eliminated, but they can be kept from growing unchecked. The aim is not to distrust every instinct. It is to notice where a successful habit may be narrowing what you hear or see.

Before your next important decision, ask someone outside your closest circle: “What do I do too much of, and what effect does it have?” Give the answer time to shape your next action.

Leaders cannot see every blind spot alone. They can make it safer for others to name what the leader has stopped noticing. Which strength do you rely on most, and who could tell you when you are overusing it?

"Because how you lead shapes what students become." A weekly moment to pause, reflect, and lead with purpose.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Sign Up form

Smart strategies for school leaders – in under 5 minutes a week.

Get weekly leadership insights —designed for educators, school leaders, and aspiring leaders.
Each issue offers a single theme, practical strategies, real-world reflections, and tools to help you lead with confidence, purpose, and impact.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.


Discover more from Dr Jake Madden

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

author avatar
Dr Jake Madden
I'm Jake Madden — educator, principal, and author with over 40 years in the field. My work centres on building teacher capacity, future-focused learning design, and global curriculum thinking. I'm especially passionate about the teacher-as-researcher and have explored these ideas through books and journal articles. I'm always learning from the field as much as contributing to it.

Author: Dr Jake Madden

I'm Jake Madden — educator, principal, and author with over 40 years in the field. My work centres on building teacher capacity, future-focused learning design, and global curriculum thinking. I'm especially passionate about the teacher-as-researcher and have explored these ideas through books and journal articles. I'm always learning from the field as much as contributing to it.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Dr Jake Madden

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading